The Plastic Problem
Plastic is truly ubiquitous. It’s in our clothes, our phones, our sunscreen. But also, increasingly, in marine food chains and immense, floating garbage patches in the oceans.
How do we fix this? Nations are trying to come up with an answer, and this year will be critical. Negotiations, which started last year and are scheduled to continue through 2023, will shape a plastics treaty expected by the end of 2024.
The talks will have to square two contrasting views of plastic: It’s a technological marvel that made a host of goods widely accessible and revolutionized medicine, but also a major contributor to climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution.
Rising consumption worldwide means the plastic waste that’s going into waterways is set to more than double, and perhaps more than triple, by 2040. Environmentalists fear production will only increase as the world quits oil and gas and fossil fuel companies pivot to plastic to sustain their profits.
Here’s what’s at stake.
How badly do we need plastics?
While it’s true that plastic is a key component in some very important things, such as medical devices, research shows that more than 40 percent of the plastic we use is packaging and generally single-use.
“Plastics are pervasive,” said Carroll Muffett, who heads the Center for International Environmental Law and has been following the treaty negotiations closely. “But it’s not the same as saying they’re truly essential.”
After all, most of you probably remember a time when soda bottles were refillable and made of glass. Going back to that system alone would have a huge impact.
Still, changing our ways will be incredibly hard. Grocery shopping used to be plastic-free. But without meaningful change in policy, Muffett said, getting back to that will most likely be very difficult. A reporter for NPR recently proved it when she tried to avoid plastics at the grocery store for just a week.
Why is plastic harmful?
Plastic has a role in both the climate and the biodiversity crises.
It’s responsible for 3.4 percent of greenhouse gas emissions, mostly because the majority of them are produced with fossil fuels. It’s killing marine life as it enters food chains or entangles animals. Plastic particles can be found in soil, water, air and also us. Some fear plastic is also interfering with the ability of the oceans to capture carbon.
“If you ask me what the potential impacts of the global plastic crisis are, we are just beginning to understand that,” Muffett told me.
A lot of plastic is also made from toxic chemicals, which make it not only harmful to us and life in general, but a lot harder to recycle. Improving this will be one of the treaty’s key goals.
What are the issues dividing nations?
Muffett explained that there are basically two sides in the negotiations.
Fifty nations have joined the High Ambition Coalition to End Plastic Pollution, which is pushing for a treaty that will limit production of plastic with binding targets for every nation that signs the pact.
Other countries, including fossil fuel-producing nations like Saudi Arabia and the United States, want a global agreement that focuses on recycling and is built on voluntary commitments, according to Climate Home News.
Advocates, like Muffett, generally prefer the first version.
First, because, so far, recycling hasn’t proven effective at the scale necessary.
Second, environmental treaties that limit production have historically been more successful. One example is the Montreal Protocol, which limited the production of chemicals that harm the ozone layer.
The conclusion of the treaty could deeply affect how we eat, clean our homes, and organize our days. So, stay tuned. We’ll be following this important story.
Essential news from The Times
California storms pose a test: As global warming brings more intense rainfall, experts say the state must give rivers more room to flood safely. But the obstacles are enormous.
Back-to-back downpours: The quick pace of storms is testing the limits of California’s infrastructure.
New air pollution rules: The Biden administration is moving to tighten limits on deadly soot from power plants, construction and other industrial activity.
Warm Europe: Countries across the continent saw the warmest start to the year ever measured. The weather has forced ski resorts to close trails.
Listen: Confronting biodiversity loss
Catrin Einhorn from the climate team joined Michael Barbaro on The Daily to talk about an ambitious new agreement to protect nature.
From outside The Times
According to a study reported by Yahoo News, gas stoves are responsible for more than 10 percent of childhood asthma cases in the United States.
A study found that warming will devastate half of all glaciers by 2100 even if nations meet their most ambitious climate goals, Climate Brief reported.
From China Dialogue: Research shows that human-caused climate change intensified the rainfall that led to the 2021 Henan floods.
Florida neighborhoods hit by hurricanes tend to gentrify, with home prices and average homeowner income rising after storms, according to Yale Environment 360.
Before you go: Has the Amazon reached a tipping point?
The Amazon has been called “the lungs of the earth” because of the amount of carbon dioxide it absorbs: According to most estimates, around half a billion tons per year. But some Brazilian scientists fear that the Amazon may become a grassy savanna — with profound effects on the climate worldwide.