Menopausal Mother Nature

News about Climate Change and our Planet


Rail Travel Is Cleaner than Driving or Flying, but Will Americans Buy in?

1The Northeast Corridor sees millions of riders a year, but expanding rail in the U.S. is always fraught. (Credit: Loco Steve, cc by-sa) Click to Enlarge.

Transportation represents a large portion – about 29 percent – of U.S. emissions, and the share has been rising in recent years.  Rail proponents often argue that investment in trains and public transportation is a key part of making transportation cleaner, and indeed, the Green New Deal calls for greatly expanding high-speed rail.

Energy and emissions profiles
Transportation by rail is a major part of the transportation system in most countries, including in the U.S., which has the longest freight railway system in the world with approximately 140,000 miles.  Rail passenger services are essential in many areas, primarily in population centers such as New York and Chicago, and intercity rail has a significant market share in some corridors, such as the Northeast.  Rail also offers long-distance routes connecting many smaller communities with each other and the large metropolitan areas in the country.

Data show that rail has a significantly lower energy footprint than trucks and passenger cars.  Rail transport, with hard steel wheels on steel rail, has lower resistance to motion than road transportation.  And the convoy formation of individual rail cars into trains also adds to its better energy and environmental performance.

A common measure for transportation capacity is ton-miles for freight and passenger-miles for passengers to indicate that a ton of freight is moved for one mile and for passenger systems that a passenger is moved for one mile.

Freight rail accounts for about one-third of the ton-miles and consumes only about 2 percent of the transportation energy in the U.S.  The higher efficiency can be illustrated this way:  On average, freight railroads move a ton of cargo for around 479 miles on a gallon of fuel, which is about 11 times more energy-efficient than trucks on a ton-mile basis.

Passenger rail is around three times more efficient than a car on a passenger-mile basis at current occupancy levels.  The lower energy consumption leads to lower greenhouse emissions.  

Read more at Rail Travel Is Cleaner than Driving or Flying, but Will Americans Buy in?